The chart below shows data for population growth pulled from the Census Wonder data system. A positive number in the “Missing” column means that the population grew by more than the net of births, naturalizations and deaths. A negative number means it grew by less than the combination of births, naturalizations and deaths.
Here’s the problem. Say you want to assume that there are 1 million illegal immigrants entering the US in 2015. To make the numbers work, you have to have more than 800,000 people living in the US leaving.
- Possible explanation 1: That’s the American Diaspora, and it appears to be quite real.
- Possible explanation 2: There’s less illegal immigration than most people think.
In 2011 and 2012, we appear to have had more people leaving the US than entering.
In fact, if Explanation 1 is true, then were we to stop illegal immigration, we would have a steady population drain and slower economic growth. Without major changes in productivity, economic growth is directly linked to the size of the workforce.
This is just a preliminary analysis. I’m looking for additional data.
You may also notice from the table that the death rate is edging upward. That’s probably just the natural result of the aging US population.